Shoe-Tying Made Simple....Just Be Sure You Read the Directions!
Today we received Shoe-Tying Made Simple by Kelly Wilk, written by an Occupational Therapist. I ordered the book through Southpaw Enterprises. I am pleased with Southpaw. The products arrive quickly and I have yet to order anything that is not worth the money. The book comes with one set of special shoe strings. I found a site where you can order additional shoe strings HERE.
Maizie is ten years old and unable to tie her own shoes. I have not pushed the issue. Recently, she has asked me to teach her. I knew this would be a challenge. Maizie has low muscle tone which makes manipulating small objects a challenge.
When I came across this book I decided it was time to give it a try. I will list the positive and negative points to this book.
Positive
*The book is divided for left handed children and right handed children
*The book stands up which makes it easy to read as you are working on the lesson
* Photos are clear and easy to decipher
*The laces are thick, the left and right side are different colors for learning purposes, have a good texture and are long enough to work with
*Teaches how to tie shoes step by step
*Advice is given on switching from a shoe on the table to the shoe on the foot
*Eventually the child may be able to switch to plain shoe laces
Negative
*The photos only show the shoe from the perspective of it facing the child. This may confuse some children. Even though shoe tying is the same if the shoe is facing you or on your foot this may be a confusing change for some children. Initially it confused me. We decided to begin learning with the shoes on Maizie's feet from the start.
*Since we chose to learn with the shoe on the foot the pictures are all backwards to Maizie
*The rhyme giving directions is a tad wordy. I had to break it down. I don't see the rhyme working for Maizie.
*Shoestrings provided are navy blue and yellow. I think Maizie will require them for quite some time so I was not thrilled with the color. This is me being picky;)
Be sure you take the time to read the directions before working with your child! Read the entire book first. It requires about thirty minutes to read the book and set up the shoes you will work with. Maizie was excited to begin so I was pressured to figure it all out without reading the book. She lost her patience with me and I became upset. I ended up having to sit alone and read the book while I prepared the shoes. Live and learn.
When the book arrives hide it until you have time to study it and prepare the shoes. One would not think setting up to teach shoe tying would take much time but it did. Especially when you consider all of our children's varying skills. You will want to be familiar with it so you can approach it with your child in a positive, well organized manner. I am easily confused and with Maizie hanging over me my first impressions of the book were not good. I kinda screwed that up. Argh.
The book is worth the money. We made more progress in one evening than all of the other times I have tried to teach her to tie her shoes. Tying shoes is something most children learn with a simple rhyme and lots of practice. For Maizie it needs to be broken down and each step will have to be practiced repeatedly before moving on to the next. This book will make that process smoother for both of us. The shoe strings are fantastic and the dual color made explaining it to Maizie easier.
I hope this review helps those of you that were questioning whether or not to buy Shoe-Tying Made Simple. Let me know how it goes! If you have any tips please share them!
A visitor told me about this website called Ian's Shoelace Site. It is full of different techniques for shoe tying.


22 comments:
I hope in tiem it comes easier to her have a great weekend and tomorrow I will post an award for you come check please.
wow. thanks for the review. I have avoided shoes with laces for J as well. right now I just can't imagine trying to teach him and he likes to be independent with his shoes so I have to keep it simple.
So glad to hear you've made really good progress with the shoe tying.
I bought a similar shoe tying book with laces some time back, but we still struggle to get shoes on Jack's feet so we haven't looked at it yet. It really is about picking the right moment isn't it!
Thanks for sharing your thoughts on the book... a great review!
xx
Thank you, that is very helpful. I've had so much trouble with my older son with laces that I just gave up and went velcro. Maybe it's time to give it another shot.
Hi Marla, my son, 9, is learning how to tie his shoes too. It's on his IEP and progress is s-l-o-w. He doesn't like to practice! He can talk me through it but has trouble with his motor skills, so we have a ways to go.
I hope you manage to get out. Cabin Fever is awful. I know what you mean about feeling cranky.
I'm embarrassed to say this something we have totally avoided. I just figured we would have velcro, slip-ons, and crocs for the rest of our lives. I think The Younger would do just fine, you wouldn't believe how he is managing with the cast. But The Elder has fine motor skills delays. He doesn't have low tone but he doesn't engage his muscles so sometimes it appears that he does. BOth girls across the street have low tone so I wonder if he is mimicking them though that doesn't sound very aspergian of him to even notice long enough to copy.
Oops, I was thinking about the last post you did about shoe tying. I read that the other day, but was unable to comment. I'm still trying to wake up this morning. I saw that you did get out the other day and I'm glad.
The photo perspective really IS bass-ackwards!
I didn't learn to tie my shoes until I was at least 8 (and I even have good fine-motor coordination). Thank heavens for those buckle-on Mary Janes!
My Kid is also slow at tying shoelaces, even at almost-17. But they're Converse and therefore cool, so laces it is! When the kids were young we had lots of shoes without laces.
Something useful I have learned about laces is to NOT by the round laces, which easily slide undone. Buy the flat sort, preferably something with cotton in it (if you can find such) as nylon fibers are more slippery.
andrea
We usually buy slip on tennis shoes for Maizie. There are so many cool alternatives these days. But, her shoe inserts for her pronating feet work best in New Balance tennis shoes and at her size they no longer make slip ons. Bummer.
Jen P-I am so glad your little guy is doing well after his surgery. Your photos of him are awesome.
Ewwww...thanks for sharing this. It could help sooo many folks out there. Keep us updated on her progress. Matty may never be able to tie his shoes but I'm going to put these links up just in case he ever does get there. :)
Great review and very helpful-----someday we'll gear ourselves up to try shoe-tying again. Charlie loves his black slip-ons and I'm not sure he'd want to be parted from them.
Wow that looks like a great book. I am having an award ceremony tomorrow and you are getting one. Dress code is PJ's and slippers, see you there.
We live and learn. A 'book' on how to tie shoelaces? I'll bet the author could also make a banquet out of a pea! In fact, you did a pretty good job yourself just in relaying the message to us. There should be a blogger's award for your efforts, seriously!
I came to you today from your comment at Crystal's place, but it's a while since you visited me?
And get those dark glasses off so we can see you! ;-)
Shoe-tying was a nighmare for Melanie and Hannah! We used velcro forever, because gym class would not let them use slip on shoes. Hannah still can't tie her shoes tightly and she is 13!! I tried so many different books, but this one sounds worth checking out, for parents at my job. I am going to share this with our OT at school too.
Velcro sneakers are great for the younger kids, but at school, when the kids get older, they are harder to find and are not "cool." So I am see kids constantly walking around with laces untied. This really would be a great resource!
XOXO
That looks like one of those books I'll need to get. I hope Maizie will soon get the hang of tying her own shoelaces :)
It sounds like there are more positives than negatives, which is good. I hope the book continues to be a help for her.
This review is very helpful! We have yet to tackle show tying either but some interest has been expressed lately.
I will have to order said book.
I like the laces of a different color. I agree thick laces are easier for kids with low fine motor strength. N1S still ties his shoes so loose that his laces are always frayed.
Oh well, they seem to grow out of shoes faster than laces anyway.
Thanks for the book tip.
Can you believe, I've tagged you again?
I'm such a pest!
Today M became pretty upset when she put on her shoes and I asked her to tie the first knot. She thought it was just too much work. Argh. I am not going to give up yet though. Maybe she was just sleepy?
Glad the review was helpful.
I have an 8 year old boy with autism... I just came across a great web site for shoelace tying...
It's great because for each of the many ways of tying shoes that it shows, you can do it by following written instructions, an animated sequence, OR a video, done from the perspective of the person tying the shoe.
For those visual learners who learn by repetition, this could be a big help!
See http://www.fieggen.com/shoelace/tying.htm
Thank you anonymous. Will post this link!
Post a Comment